Fourteen year old Terri Anderson was very pretty, vivacious and full of life. Though the Homolka's were never charged with her murder, it's pretty certain that they are responsible for her life as well. Just a month after the nude body of Kristen French was found naked in a ditch, investigators found the naked body of Terri Anderson in the waters at Port Dalhousie, it was May 23, 1992. Terri was an excellent student, cheerleader and all around good kid, despite this, the medical examiner found no sings of foul play. Of course, signs of anything would have been very difficult to obtain as Terri's body had been in the water for six months. The coroner ruled that Terri died from drowning, due to alcohol and LSD.

Stephan Williams had this to say, "Inspector Bevan and the coroner were asking Mr. Anderson to accept that his daughter had, under the influence of a few beers and a hit of blotter acid, gone out and in a stupor neither he nor her friends had perceived, walked into the freezing November waters of Lake Ontario and drowned."